World Premiere · Rochester Fringe Festival · September 2026

MASS DRAG

How the Catholic Church Came to Bless Gay Love … Again
A Drag Liturgy in One Act
Five drag nuns. A gay bar.
A thousand years of queer Catholic history
the Church keeps trying to erase.
One High Drag Mass.
Rochester Fringe Festival · September 2026

The Show

It’s October 9, the anniversary of the canonization of Saint John Henry Newman, a Victorian cardinal who loved another man for thirty-two years, asked to share his grave for eternity, and was made a saint anyway.

Five Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence are performing a High Drag Mass in a gay bar. They follow the full structure of the Catholic liturgy — processional, readings, homily, offering, communion, recessional. But the sacred texts are Newman’s love letters, Vatican dossiers, and a saint who turned up missing from his grave.

The Sisters argue all night about whether to pursue beatification for their fallen Sister Donna Wanna Noh. Underneath that argument is the show’s real question: why do we keep asking for the blessing of an institution that has tried to bury us?

Part queer history lesson. Part liturgical comedy. Part revival meeting.
Original book, music, and lyrics.

A Timeline
4th–13th
Centuries
Documented same-sex union ceremonies in the Catholic Church
14th–17th
Centuries
Men tried by Church inquisitions for sodomy, then burned at the stake
1890 As insisted in his will, Cardinal Newman is buried with his beloved Ambrose St. John
2008 Cardinal Newman’s grave exhumed, to have his remains separated from Ambrose St. John
2019 John Henry Newman canonized — a saint who asked to share another man’s grave for eternity
2026 World premiere at Rochester Fringe Festival. The Sisters are ready.
The Playwright

James Lopata wrote the book, music, and lyrics for Mass Drag. He holds a Master of Theological Studies from Harvard Divinity School and is a Harvard Institute of Coaching Fellow. He studied playwriting with Nobel Laureate Derek Walcott and spent years as cantor at St. Francis Xavier Church in Manhattan — one of New York’s most celebrated progressive Catholic communities. He has more than thirty years of Zen practice and founded the Massachusetts LGBT Chamber of Commerce.

He knows the history in this play from the inside. The Catholic liturgy, the queer grief, the spiritual hunger, the dark comedy of an institution that keeps blessing and erasing the same love. Mass Drag is the show he was always going to write.